Thinking what others are not thinking
In the uncertain world of investing, evolutionary instincts sometimes lead us to see patterns when there are none.
While humans are susceptible to biological weaknesses when it comes to investing, computers and machines suffer from a lack of perspective. Most of the research in machine learning and artificial intelligence is on reverse engineering how the human brain processes information. Computers can process a vast amount of information, but that still doesn’t solve the problem of finding patterns that may not exist.
Our approach is to be objective and we want to be bold, but we don’t let our conviction bend toward obsession, and so “when the facts change, we change our mind”. However, “facts” under our approach are not others’ interpretation of information (which allows us to see things form a different viewpoint). While we are open and flexible to changing our mind when the facts change, our investment philosophy is fixed. Avoiding to buy expensive and crowded assets may cost us short-term potential performance, but we prefer the pain of discipline (adhering to our process) over the pain of regret (chasing pure momentum or what’s working).
Going into 2017
Investors were convinced that a higher US dollar was a sure bet because the US Federal Reserve was the only central bank which was on a tightening cycle. Monetary policy divergence was a valid theme over the past few years which had already led to a significant US dollar appreciation. But it was an old theme which was being overplayed through extrapolation (and imagination) and not evidence. The evidence at the time was pointing to monetary policy convergence. We saw the same data that others could see, but thought differently. At the end, it was the global growth contagion and the resulting monetary policy convergence that derailed the one-way traffic in US dollar buying. The sharp sell-off in USD in recent months shows how unprepared the market was for this scenario.
But there is still another missing piece to the global reflation theme: The collapse in bond yields, and a fall in inflation expectations are inconsistent with the global reflation theme. The resulting market leadership in the same old defensive growth sectors, the underperformance of value over growth sectors (e.g. underperformance of financials and energy sectors) and the underperformance of European and Japanese equities against US equities all have their roots in inflation disappointment and falling bond yields of recent months (this has led to the flat lining of the Fund’s performance in recent months). But what if, bond traders are doing what USD dollar traders were doing at the start of the year? That is, doubling down on the old game of quantitative easing and easy money and disinflation forever? We think they are. If so, bonds are likely to be the next shoe to drop (although unlikely to be the same pace as the sharp USD sell-off. Why?
Markets have spent most of 2017 pricing out the frantic and unrealistic expectations of a huge growth and inflation uplift following Trump’s election. But the sentiment pendulum seems to have once again moved to the opposite end of the spectrum where there is little prospect of inflation being priced in. Underneath the daily noise we see two key facts:
- Major economies are growing in sync for the first time in a decade;
- Central banks have made it clear that Quantitative Easing (QE) is ending and Quantitative Tightening (QT) is coming.
With global growth gaining traction, loan demand on the mend and bank balance sheets in a much better shape, a perverse positive correlation between Quantitative Tightening (QT) and rising inflation might soon develop. The most likely outcome here is a slowdown in asset price inflation and a recovery in consumer price inflation. Any signs of inflation and a more hawkish (or less dovish) central bank will catch the markets (the bond market in particular) off guard.
Risks and opportunities over the months ahead
- A sharp bond sell-off spills into bond proxies and QE winners and drags down the broader market with it. Given US share market’s uninterrupted gains over the past 12 months a correction is overdue. A bond market sell-off can provide the trigger.
- An inflation surprise in the US (against the low expectations), pushes up USD and bond yields higher at the same time, leading to a tightening of financial conditions. EM equities, and high yield corporate bonds will likely to be the key casualties (bearing in mind that US dollar sentiment is now at pessimistic extremes in a sharp contrast to the bullish extreme at the start of the year).
- Signs of an inflation trough will put a floor under inflation expectations and nominal bond yields. Central banks remain on track for gentle tightening and balance sheet unwind.
- The gentle transition from QE to QT sees a leadership change to value over growth (bearing in mind that value-to-growth ratio has tracked bond yields down for 10 years from 2007).
Fund positioning in response
- High cash exposure - cash gives us the optionality to buy the market at lower price).
- Put options on EM equities and US high yield corporate bonds - EM equities and US HY bonds have been the biggest beneficiaries of the recent fall in market expectations for further rate hikes in the US. Bearing in mind that with financial conditions in the US easier now than before the first rate hike, it’s unlikely that the Fed is done with rate hikes in contrast with the current market expectations.
- Long USD against EM FX - Any US inflation surprise (against very low expectations) and a less dovish stance by the US Fed will likely trigger a rebound USD against EM FX (given that sentiment toward USD is at pessimistic extremes and for EM FX at optimist extremes).
- Concentration in equity exposure to sectors leveraged to global growth (materials, transportations, energy)
- Allocation to sectors benefiting from the transition from QE to QT and most notably allocation to European, Japanese and US banks.
- Allocation to commodities (total allocation of 14% in commodities): Multiple years of commodity weakness following post GFC’s “new normal” in the macro backdrop leaves plenty of catch up room as we move back to the “old normal” of synchronised global growth. The Bloomberg Commodity Index demand vs supply indicates early recovery similar to what was seen after the GFC but with a foundation of prolonged price declines. Furthermore, Agricultural commodities may be heading into a perfect storm for higher prices supported by record US exports, massive drop in plantation acreage, tight inventories, and the increasing likelihood of adverse weather impact (e.g. multiple hurricane in the US, flooding etc).
Head of Dynamic Markets
Important information: This email has been prepared by AMP Capital Investors Ltd (ABN 59 001 777 591, AFSL 232497) ("AMP Capital"). BetaShares Capital Ltd (ACN 139 566 868, AFSL 341181 ("BetaShares")) is the responsible entity and the issuer of units in the AMP CAPITAL DYNAMIC MARKETS FUND (HEDGE FUND) (the “Fund”). AMP Capital is the investment manager of the Fund and has been appointed by the responsible entity to provide investment management and associated services in respect of the Fund. To invest in a Fund, investors will need to obtain the current Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) available from AMP Capital. The PDS contains important information about investing in a Fund and it is important that investors read the PDS before making a decision about whether to acquire, or continue to hold or dispose of units in the Fund. None of AMP Capital, AMPCFM, nor any other company in the AMP Group guarantees the repayment of capital or the performance of any product or any particular rate of return referred to in this document.
The information in this document is provided only for the use of advisers/financial planners; it is not intended for investors. This information provides a brief overview of some of the benefits of investing in a Fund. The adviser/financial planner remains responsible for any advice/services they provide to clients, including making their own inquiries and ensuring that the advice/services are appropriate and in accordance with all legal requirements. Therefore advisers/financial planners must not attribute any advice/service to AMP Capital or in any way suggest AMP Capital is the author of any part of that advice/service.
Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. As advisers/financial planners invest through an investment platform, this presentation shows platform class A performance after the deduction of platform class A fees. Please refer to our website for performance figures for direct investment class H. While every care has been taken in the preparation of this presentation, AMP Capital makes no representation or warranty as to the accuracy or completeness of any statement in it including without limitation, any forecasts. This document has been prepared for the purpose of providing general information, without taking account of any particular investor’s objectives, financial situation or needs. Investors should, before making any investment decisions, consider the appropriateness of the information in this document, and seek professional advice, having regard to their objectives, financial situation and needs.